At the first trial, prosecutors painted Rinderknecht as a man mad at the world, citing passenger accounts of him ranting at them on New Year’s Eve.
Rinderknecht “was angry all the time” and “believed he was enslaved by the wealthy,” Assistant U.S. Attorney Danbee Kim told the court.
At the second trial, prosecutors seeking to convict Rinderknecht built a case against him using surveillance camera footage of his car driving in the Pacific Palisades neighborhood before the fire, GPS location information, and a green Bic barbecue lighter.
“It’s not the traditional smoker’s lighter that I’m used to seeing,” LAPD Detective Matt Castellichio testified for the prosecution.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Mark Williams said in closing arguments Wednesday that DNA from the lighter matched Rinderknecht’s DNA.
Defense attorney Steve Haney said Rinderknecht admitted earlier to investigators he had the lighter with him. He said investigators found it in the glove compartment of his rental car, not at the scene of the Lachman Fire.
After dropping off a passenger in the Palisades, Rinderknecht decided to walk up what’s known as Hidden Buddha Hill hoping to see some fireworks in the distance and ring in the new year, Haney said.
After the environmental sensing platforms detected the Lachman Fire, Rinderknecht called 911 several times but his cellphone was out of service range.
Those calls, Williams told the jury, were to create an alibi, and Rinderknecht had asked ChatGPT whether a person was at fault if a wildfire was caused by their cigarette.
Rinderknecht also recorded images of the fire, Williams said.
“The only verdict you can reach is guilty,” Williams said in his closing argument Wednesday.
Haney said Rinderknecht should be acquitted because nobody saw him start the fire, no camera recorded the blaze being ignited, and that evidence at the site of the Lachman Fire had been compromised because the scene was open to the public for several days before it was closed by police.
Ed Nordskog, a retired Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department arson and bomb investigator, testified earlier for the defense that “it appears hundreds of people visited the scene before it was locked down.”
“In my experience, we call it a case killer,” Nordskog testified.

The Palisades Fire burned 23,448 acres, resulted in 12 deaths and destroyed 6,837 homes, businesses and other structures, according to the Los Angeles Fire Department.
Starting in the Santa Monica Mountains, it burned through the Pacific Palisades neighborhood and then spread rapidly through the Los Angeles County communities of Topanga and Malibu.
It was more than three weeks before firefighters were able to corral the fire and the blaze wasn’t completely contained until Jan. 31, 2025.
Los Angeles City Council member Traci Park, who represents the Palisades, said “there is no amount of courtroom justice that will ever undo the harm that was caused.”
“What happened was just so deeply personal and traumatic,” she told NBC Los Angeles outside court Friday.
The Los Angeles Fire Department thanked the jurors.
“Our first thought remains with the families of those we lost and for everyone in our community whose lives were changed by this fire,” it said in a statement Friday. “No verdict, however important, could ever undo that loss.”
Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass, who was criticized for being out of the country when the fire erupted, and who lost re-election earlier this month, said that the fire “devastated our city, taking innocent lives, destroying thousands of homes, and changing so many lives and Los Angeles forever.”
“No verdict can bring back the lives lost or erase the pain families have endured,” Bass said in a statement. “So many are still struggling to rebuild. For those still displaced, the devastation remains a daily reality.”
The juror in the second trial who gave his name as Cameron said that the panel weighed the evidence carefully and knew that whatever they decided would have serious ramifications on Rinderknecht’s life.
The juror couldn’t say whether he believed Rinderknecht intended to burn down the Palisades.
“His intent was to start a fire,” the juror said. “What that fire did after his actions — whether he can say it, or whether no one can say it, who knows — only he will know and only God will know.”
“The result of his fire is what ultimately led to January 7th,” the juror said.
